Top Best American Restaurants in Buffalo City

"Blue Moon Beach Grill is, in its own words, “a quirky, fun-filled dining experience,” and we couldn’t agree more, except to add the descriptions delicious, friendly and affordable. Family-owned, they serve a great mix of Southern comfort food, fresh, local seafood and creative lunch and dinner specials. Menu favorites include the fish tacos, shrimp and grits, crab cakes, and the Philly cheesesteak."

"Blue Moon Beach Grill is a fun-filled and quirky dining experience situated along South Croatan Highway in Nags Head, North Carolina. The restaurant specializes in Southern comfort food while offering creative twists on classic favorites. The restaurant’s space is cozy, features original artwork throughout, and delivers a nautical theme."

"Sam & Omie's Restaurant in Nags Head maintains its seaside flavor more than 70 years later. The place exudes a barefoot and beachy atmosphere and serves up plenty of tasty dishes morning, noon and night, including omelets,hamburgers, club sandwiches and prime rib or seafood dinners. Address:7228 S Virginia Dare Trl, Nags Head, NC 27959"

"Best crab cake sandwich I've ever had, and the tuna steak is unbelievable. Jamie was an amazing server and even though I haven't been in almost three... (252) 441-7366Order online"

"From Business: Started in 1937, Sam & Omie's Restaurant caters to the needs of customers in Nags Head in North Carolina. The restaurant provides breakfast and dinner options,…"

"Fantastic waterfront views and great food are staples at Stripers Bar & Grill. It’s the perfect casual date night spot, especially if you are staying in one of our Shallowbag Bay condo rental properties."

"Outer Banks Brewing Station has an ever-changing list of award-winning house-made beers that serve as the cornerstone of their innovative style. Multiple year winners of the Taste of the Beach People's Choice Award, their outstanding chefs have created an Outer Banks–inspired fusion menu using regionally available products from local fish and produce to North Carolina meats. Pastry chef Tina Mackenzie bakes the house bread and...read moreOuter Banks Brewing Station has an ever-changing list of award-winning house-made beers that serve as...read more"

"If you want to grab a locally made craft beer and some tasty grub, then you will love the Outer Banks Brewing Station. This restaurant in Kill Devil Hills also serves as an entertainment hub, where walls of TVs and live music provide a great atmosphere for watching a big game or taking in some live music."

"While it's not technically in Nags Head, this brewpub in neighboring Kill Devil Hills is worth a stop: Their handcrafted beers are made on-site in a wind-powered brewery. Plus, they serve wine and cocktails for those few who aren't riding the craft brew train."

"Tropical Smoothie offers great fruit smoothies in such a wide variety that it's hard to choose a flavor, but they have more than smoothies. They also serve salads, wraps and sandwiches. Light fare and kids' meals are available."

"In 2021 Jennette’s Pier celebrates its 10-year anniversary since reopening in 2011 as part of the North Carolina Aquariums division. Known as “the place to be” in Nags Head during the summer season, anglers catch a wide variety of fish while sightseers can watch brown pelicans overhead and bottlenose dolphins swimming in the sea.The pier is surrounded by wide, clean public beaches, free parking...read moreIn 2021 Jennette’s Pier celebrates its 10-year anniversary since reopening in 2011 as part of...read more"

"Sandwiches, burgers, and wraps are the highlights on the menu at Poor Richard’s Sandwich Shop. The is one of our favorite restaurants in Manteo, North Carolina, to grab lunch. It sits in the heart of town, so you can easily walk to it if you’re staying in one of our historic cottages."

"Poor Richard's is the local meet-and-greet neighborhood sandwich shop by day and bar by night. It has two doors, one leading from the Manteo boardwalk and another off Queen Elizabeth Avenue. You can eat inside at a booth or table or sit outside on the patio right next to the water."

"The 5-acre Dowdy Park is a popular place for relaxation, play and entertainment. The park includes an amphitheater, green space, restrooms, a fitness trail, basketball and pickleball courts, a bocce area and an unusual playscape/playground for kids, and it's the site of local events, festivals and live music. You'll find it on the Bypass in Nags Head, next to Nags Head Elementary School on the...read more"

"Take a play break for the small ones at this wonderful park. Watch your kids run up and down the hills as they jump from swing to swing. The Foam shaped mountains or a great workout and wave to get all of your children’s energy out before bed or naptime."

"Mahi Mahi’s Island Grill features American cuisine with a dash of Latin flavor and a strong emphasis on seafood. Owners Andrew and Leslie Mikhail have proudly partnered with Peruvian-born Chef Alfredo Landazuri to establish this new Outer Banks restaurant where customers can expect an affordable menu, quality ingredients and friendly service. After working in and opening different restaurants along the Outer Banks and winning first-place awards...read moreMahi Mahi’s Island Grill features American cuisine with a dash of Latin flavor and a strong...read more"

"We had the tuna nachos and the caprese salad as well as the key lime pie. Points off for the blue lives matter flag up…”more"

"Founded in 1998 by Chef Craig Errickson and Brian Brown, the Red Drum Tap House restaurant is situated along Virginia Dare Trail in Nags Head, North Carolina. The restaurant gets its name from a delicious fish that can be found in the local waters of the Outer Banks. A fitting name for a restaurant that serves fresh, local seafood as well as spicy ribs, juicy steaks, stuffed chicken, and many more tempting dishes."

"Red Drum Grille & Taphouse has been a go-to Nags Head restaurant for locals and visitors alike for nearly two..."